Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Beach Reading with The Pact

Alright, I promised book reviews. The first of many:

The Pact by Jodi Picoult

I always had reservations when it came to Jodi Picoult. Not because I've heard good or bad things about her work, not because her novels seem to be everywhere, not because my mother can't stop talking about Nineteen Minutes. Honestly? My reservations come from the fact that friends recommend them to me during the summer. Weird, right?

I think my aversion to particular novels, especially Jodi Picoult novels, comes from the fact that I hate it when books are referred to/recommended as "Beach Reads". I hate the title "Beach Read". In my head, it's such a negative label. It implies that the writing is only worthwhile if you're sitting in the sun, with seagulls overhead, and only pausing in your reading to slap on some heavily scented suntan lotion. Beach Reads are good to crack open when you're on vacation, and outside of the white sand and sea-salted air, they're not worth anyone's time.

Please don't get me wrong; it's not that I'm overly passionate about Jodi Picoult or any other author whose work is referred to as a Beach Read. It's that the label, as well as being negative, also implies that it's an easy read; something that anyone without a brain could read. The writing has been dumbed down, so it's accessible to everyone. Beach Reads, dumbed down. Dumbed writing. Dumbed down, dumbed writing, for dumb people.

Now, I may not be the smartest person alive, but I am by no means a dumb person. I'm a writer, and my writing may be (somewhat) unpublished, but it's not dumb. I read a lot; I'll read anything, but I don't waste my time on dumb material and I am a far cry from what some people refer to as a dumb reader. I won't ever win a Scholarly Reader Award, but I like to think that I'm fairly educated when it comes to the material I spend my time ingesting. I mean, hell, I have to be a somewhat educated reader in order to write my own stuff, and I have to be even more educated than that in order to edit. (And for those of you wondering, yes, I get paid to do both.)

So why would I want to pick up a novel that my friends inadvertently imply is a good, dumb summer read?

Answer is: I wouldn't.

Jodi Picoult, my friends, is not a Beach Read. Her novels are good to read at the beach, they're good to read during the summer, but they're not limited to the sun-and-fun of June, July, and August. I have my reservations with her work only being offered during this glorious off time, but after reading The Pact, I have no reservations when it comes to actually reading her work.

The Pact is not some easy, cheesy quick read. It's quite the opposite, with it's intensely heavy subject matter and complex characters who hold a complex past. Suicide is the main theme of the story, with undertones of love between friends who are family, and the loss of innocence and life. The story of Emily and Chris, two neighboring 17 y.o. whose fates are inexplicably intertwined, are pieced together throughout the novel, through various POVs.

When it comes to personal reactions:

I didn't have a favorite part in the novel. I knew the ending before I knew the beginning, so everything leading up to the last few pages was shadowed in heartbreak. I did appreciate the character development, especially in the parental units. Very true to life. Emily was very well written. Chris...I don't know. I felt he could have used a little bit more depth. Can't put my finger on why. Plot was scary, because that's the truth for some teenagers. The trial was better than the trial in My Sister's Keeper.

The only thing that drove me batty was the interview at the end, in which JP indicates she'd have preferred a different ending, but was worried about reader reactions. Personally, I can't stand it when authors cater to readers. Readers aren't the point of writing a book; the entire reason for penning a book is because of the characters. Characters are the reason for writing, and it's their tale that's being permanently inked into paper. No one but the author can reiterate this-or-that particular story, because the characters don't speak to anyone else. For that reason, and that reason alone, the author should do everything in his/her power to do the character(s) and/or storyline justice. Even if it means pissing off or losing readers. Everyone is going to have an opinion (this post: case and point) but not everyone can give the characters what they need.

I won't say that JP's comment ruined the story for me, because it didn't. I did feel, however, that the ending wasn't what was best for the story. I would have preferred the ending that JP mentioned in her interview, because it would have put the characters before the readers. That ending would have been harder to read, but I would have respected that ending more, because it wasn't the easy way out.



Other than that, I'd recommend the book. I don't recommend it as a Beach Read, but it'd be something to read at the beach, if you're alright with crying in front of tons of people you don't know.


4 stars out of 5. If that's what you look for in reviews.

No comments: