I finished reading The Horse God Built: The Untold Story of Secretariat, the World's Greatest Racehorse by Lawrence Scanlan.
I thought it was a good, journalistic portrayal of a writer on a quest to personally understand a force bigger than himself. I was both satisfied and frustrated with this particular piece of nonfiction.
The novel was well researched, which is always appreciated. The writing was well done. Scanlan had a tendency to be both lyrical and sharp, with imagery as well as personal writing style. I enjoyed the pictures, simply because I didn't know much about the horse, prior to the novel. After I finished reading, I did research, which led me to numerous photographs, newspaper articles, and recommendations for further reading.
All in all, I thought that the novel was a good time-filler, but nothing urgent that needs to be read. My major complaints revolved around "outer textual" things, such as the title, the back abstract, and the cover photograph. The title and back blurb contradict one another. Is the book about The Untold Story of Secretariat, or is it The Untold Story of Secretariat and His Groom, Eddie Sweat? If the book is supposed to be about a horse and his groom, and if all of the content is arguing the mistreatment of grooms (Eddie Sweat in particular), then why was the groom not on the cover photograph?
It leads me back to my main question, "What is this novel really about?" Upon reflection, I don't think this book was really about a relationship between a horse and his groom. For all of the correct journalistic approaches, there was too much of the author in the novel. I had a hard time separating his voice and opinion from the presentation of historical background and facts. Everything seemed to come back to how he retraced the horse's hoof steps, how a large number of fans responded to his inquiries about the racehorse, and how he believed Sweat and Secretariat lived, loved, and raced. The overwhelming number of personal interviews (what I consider "elbow rubbing") only reinforces my impression of the author and his approach to the novel.
Anyways. I don't think there's anything wrong with this approach to nonfiction (it's called creative nonfiction and I LOVE this "new" type of genre) but if you're like me, looking for a serious piece of nonfiction, then I wouldn't recommend this book. If you'd like to check out a novel surrounding a writer's journey to understand historical events, then you'll probably like this book. It's all personal taste.
In other news:
Made Italian marinated, grilled chicken and homemade potato salad for the second time in six days. Whew.
Was not a fan of Glee.
Am halfway through Conspiracy In Death by JD Robb.
Am also halfway through James and the Giant Peach...again. :D :D :D
Washed, waxed, and polished my little XA today and it looks AH-MAZING.
Murphy's manners have veered towards awful. Reviewing obedience this summer is DEF going to happen.
Post from my University Blog, dated 9-13-07. This was a requirement for my Senior Seminar Poetic Praxis course.
Late Air
Elizabeth Bishop
From a magician’s midnight sleeve
the radio-singers
distribute all their love-songs
over the dew-wet lawns.
And like a fortune-teller’s
their marrow-piercing guesses are whatever you believe.
But on the Navy Yard aerial I find
better witness
for love on summer nights.
Five remote red lights
keep their nests there; Phoenixes
burning quietly, where the dew cannot climb.